Make a Payment | Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance

Click here to make a one-time payment online
No account login required.

Click here to login or to set up an account to make a payment

Give us a call!
Call 800.477.1660 to make a payment or if you have questions regarding your bill.

Mail your payments to:
Indiana Farmers Mutual, P.O. Box 856, Indianapolis, IN 46206

Overnight your payments to:
Indiana Farmers Mutual, 10 W. 106th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46290

Payment FAQ

Q:	When will I receive my bill?
A:	Your bill is sent 21 days in advance of the effective date or your billing due date.

Q:	How do I change my bill method?
A:	Please contact your agent to change your billing method and to learn about all of our pay plans.

Q:	How can I pay automatically?
A:	There are two options to pay automatically: recurring credit card and EFT. To sign up for recurring credit card, either contact your agent or log into your account and select the policies that you would like to pay for with a credit card. To sign up for EFT please contact your agent to get the forms that need to be signed for this pay plan.

Q:	I would like to make my payment via my checking account. Is that an option?
A:	Yes. When you login to make your payment choose the echeck option and this will be one-time payment from your checking account.

Q:	Are you able to combine my homeowner and auto policy together into one bill?
A:	Not at this time, but this is a planned future enhancement.

Q:	Why did I receive a Final Notice of Cancellation/Expiration? I have paid all invoices received.
A:	You may have only paid the invoice from one of your policy terms. If you feel there has been an error, please contact us at 800.477.1660.

Q:	Can I split my payment between two different credit cards?
A:	Yes. Please call Customer Service at 800.477.1660 from 7:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Monday through Friday.

Q:	Where can I find my online payment number?
A:	Your online payment number can be found on your invoice. If your invoice is not available please call Customer Service at 800.477.1660 from 7:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Monday through Friday. A representative can supply you with your online payment number or take your payment over the phone.

Payment FAQ

Q. When will I receive my bill?

Your bill is sent 21 days in advance of the effective date or your billing due date.

Q. How do I change my bill method?

Please contact your agent to change your billing method and to learn about all of our pay plans.

Q. How can I pay automatically?

There are two options to pay automatically: recurring credit card and EFT. To sign up for recurring credit card, either contact your agent or log into your account and select the policies that you would like to pay for with a credit card. To sign up for EFT please contact your agent to get the forms that need to be signed for this pay plan.

Q. I would like to make my payment via my checking account. Is that an option?

Yes. When you login to make your payment choose the echeck option and this will be one-time payment from your checking account.

Q. Are you able to combine my homeowner and auto policy together into one bill?

Not at this time, but this is a planned future enhancement.

Q. Why did I receive a Final Notice of Cancellation/Expiration? I have paid all invoices received.

You may have only paid the invoice from one of your policy terms. If you feel there has been an error, please contact us at 800.477.1660.

Q. Can I split my payment between two different credit cards?

Yes. Please call Customer Service at 800.477.1660 from 7:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Monday through Friday.

Q. Where can I find my online payment number?

Your online payment number can be found on your invoice. If your invoice is not available please call Customer Service at 800.477.1660 from 7:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Monday through Friday. A representative can supply you with your online payment number or take your payment over the phone.